Free Continental US Shipping On Orders $45+


Healthy Peanut Butter & Jelly Oatmeal Cookies

Today, we're diving into a nostalgic treat that will not only remind you of your childhood, but also has the twist of beautifying benefits!  Yes, you heard that right – cookies that taste like your youth AND will have you glowing from within! How can you possibly say no? Our Peanut Butter and Jelly Oatmeal Cookies are a simply delicious cookie made from classic rolled oats, creamy peanut butter and of course, you can’t forget about the jelly! It’s just like your favorite childhood sandwich, but in a healthy cookie form! 

Every ingredient in this cookie recipe is rather important, but the one we want to make sure you remember to include in your cookie is our Original Beauty Plant-Based Collagen Support Blend. This special ingredient is made with the most amazing herbalist-approved plant-botanicals like amla berry, tremella mushroom extract, and gotu kola that support your hair, skin, and nail health. All of our collagen support blends help your body produce more of its own collagen naturally whilst also fighting against collagen degradation. That being said, Original Beauty holds an extra special place in our heart for being our OG blend. After all, it's in the name 😉 

Our Original Beauty Blend is the most versatile blend out of the four blends we offer here at Copina Co because it doesn’t have a very distinct taste. You can add it to your lattes or baked goods without changing the flavor of your beverage or snack, making it one of our more popular collagen support blends. That reason alone was exactly why we chose to include our Original Beauty Blend over our Vanilla Beauty Blend in our Peanut Butter and Jelly Oatmeal Cookie recipe. We still wanted to incorporate those wellness benefits, but didn’t want to compromise that classic PB & J flavor.

Let’s get into the rest of the ingredients!

Rolled Oats: The base of this cookie is made from old-fashioned rolled oats. Oats are a great source of fiber and antioxidants. Once baked, the oatmeal in our cookie recipe will have a slightly crisp edge and a soft and chewy center, making for the perfect bite. If you are looking to add even more oatmeal based recipes to your cookbook, check out some of our other recipes like our ‘No Bake Cacao Cookies’ and our ‘Collagen Boosting Beauty Bites’.

Banana: The key to getting a super soft center to your cookie is by adding in a ripe banana. The softer the banana, the chewier the cookie! Bananas are high in potassium and other nutrients and a staple ingredient in this PB & J Oatmeal Cookie Recipe. 

Vanilla Extract: Now, we’re moving on to the smaller pantry staples. Adding in a dash of vanilla extract to this recipe will add a touch of sweetness. If you are one who has a bigger sweet tooth, add in a touch more vanilla, and perhaps consider swapping out our Original Beauty Collagen Support Blend for our Vanilla Beauty Collagen Support Blend like we mentioned above. If you’re going to add in more vanilla, you might as well make that vanilla flavor even more prominent, right?!

Maple syrup: Maple syrup is another ingredient that can contribute to the sweetness of your cookie, and it also helps crisp up the edges of your cookie in the baking process. Try to avoid using “breakfast syrup” which doesn’t have the same powerful maple flavor that pure syrup contains.

Cinnamon: Cinnamon is just another one of those staple ingredients that we always feel compelled to add into our recipes. It pairs so seamlessly with the oats, and makes the recipe feel complete.

Creamy Peanut Butter: What would a Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookie be without the peanut butter?! Creamy peanut butter is the way to go if you want your cookies to stay nice and soft. Crunchy peanut butter tends to make them crumbly because it's thicker and, well, less creamy! So, for cookies that hold together well and stay soft, stick with creamy peanut butter.

Jelly: Peanut butter’s partner in crime … jelly! This is where you can start to personalize your cookie a little bit. You can use a classic strawberry jam for your jelly center, or you may want to opt in for a blackberry jam. Whichever flavor you prefer, we just suggest you try and find some locally made jam for more natural and less processed ingredients.

Chocolate Chips: The final ingredient to top your cookie with is some melted dark chocolate chips! Drizzle a little bit of this on your PB & J cookies for some extra ooey gooey goodness! If you really want to get fancy with it, you can mix in our Cacao Beauty Plant-Based Collagen Support Blend into your melted chocolate for an extra boost of collagen support.

After making these cookies, your kitchen will be sure to smell amazing. These cookies are not only delicious but also packed with wholesome ingredients to fuel your body and soul. Check our other blog posts for more beautifying and wellness based dessert recipes!

Vegan White Chocolate Rice Crispy Treats

Vegan Peach Cobbler Beauty Popsicles

Vegan Chocolate Brownie Smoothie

Vanilla Beauty Yogurt Bark




Older Post
Newer Post

Related Posts

Erewhon-Inspired Mango Lemonade Slushie
Erewhon-Inspired Mango Lemonade Slushie
With the warmer months finally here, there's nothing that quite hits the spot like a refreshing, hydrating drink to c...
Read More
Homemade Sea Moss Gatorade for Hydration
Homemade Sea Moss Gatorade for Hydration
There is nothing we love more than a drink that not only tastes amazing but also helps us stay hydrated and get an ab...
Read More
Blueberry Cheesecake Smoothie for Health
Blueberry Cheesecake Smoothie for Health
Craving a delicious sweet treat that is completely vegan and collagen supporting? If so, you’ve come to the right pla...
Read More